Bay Street Theater Celebrates 35 Years! Sag Harbor NY

2U U2 Tribute Band Live at Bay Street Theater | March 21, 2026

THE JOY OF IMPROV - Starting March 2 - Bay Street Theater

3 Decades Rewind

The Fireside Sessions - Nancy Atlas and Brian Mitchell

Don’t Miss This Summer at Bay Street Theater | 2026

JILL GIOIA Sings STREISAND - Sag Harbor - April 18

Mister Halston | World Premiere at Bay Street Theater | Sag Harbor

SUMMER SEASON 2026 Bay Street Theater

Behind the Seams: Matt McGrath on Mister Halston

A Moment with the Playwright of Mister Halston - Bay Street Theater, NY

Bonkers in the Boroughs | World Premiere Comedy by Joy Behar - Sag Harbor NY

Final Week for Bonnie & Clyde The Musical

Give the Gift of Live Theater | Bay Street Theater

New Years Laughin Eve Bay Street Theater

Before Stranger Things, There Was Fahrenheit 451 — Final Weekend at Bay Street!

🔥 Bay Street Theater Ignites the Stage with Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 🔥

What Book Would You Save - Fahrenheit 451

The New York Bee Gees are coming to Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor | April 11