With a trophy to defend and expectations to match, the Crew opened their Leagues Cup campaign hoping to rediscover the magic that fueled last year’s title run — but the night didn’t unfold as planned.

Columbus Crew blew a 2-0 lead against Toluca FC in the Leagues Cup group stage, and went to PKs where they fell 4-2.

Players percentage of pass that is successful and ends in a player’s own half of the pitch ranking during the Leagues Cup 2025 season on AS.com ...