Customers who bought any flavor or package size of Poppi soda from Jan. 23, 2020, to July 18, 2025, are eligible for payment. Those who can provide proof of purchase can receive 75 cents per can, $3 per four-pack, $6 per eight-pack and $9 per 12- or 15-pack. Payments could vary depending on the number of claims filed.

In June 2024, a woman in California hit Poppi with a lawsuit, claiming that the soda is "falsely advertised as being good for gut health when they contain minimal prebiotics and a high sugar content." Now,